OPINIONS
OPINIONS
Cambodian
and Thai
Martial Arts Explained
By Antonio Graceffo
Since the launch of my web TV show, “Martial Arts Odyssey,” more than 18 months ago, I have received a lot of email asking about Khmer and Thai martial arts, what they are, and which is better.
This is just a brief overview to help people understand the martial arts
of Cambodia and Thailand. You can also google my name, plus the words
“Khmer martial arts” or Muay Thai and find more in-depth stories I have
done on those arts. Also, you can see “Martial Arts Odyssey” on youtube,
for free. Or you can get some of my books on
amazon.com
Martial Arts Odyssey
http://ca.youtube.com/results?
Cambodia has exactly three martial arts.
1. Bradal Serey (Pradal Serey), which is kick boxing, with nearly
exactly
the same rules and style as Muay Thai. Bradal Serey is the national
sport,
and the national television networks features professional fights
weekly.
2. Bokator (Boxkator) which is an all encompassing ancient fighting art,
includes punches, kicks, knees, elbows, grappling, ground fighting, and
weapons. The practitioners fight without gloves. Their hands are wrapped
with ropes or traditional krama scarves.
3. Japbab Boran Khmer (Khmer wrestling) The least practiced of the Khmer
martial arts. There are a handful of wrestling clubs country wide. They
meet annually for the national wrestling competition, which is a big
spectator event. In Khmer wrestling, the goal is to force the opponent’s
back onto the ground.
There are numerous Khmer words which mean fighting or martial art Khorm
Yuth, Labok Katao, Kbach Kun Khmer, Wy Khun, Yuthakun, Yuth....but it is
all either Bokator or Bradal Serey. One more name I found on the web was
Kbach Kun Dambong Veng, which just means short Khmer fighting stick. It
is
not a separate art but just a small piece of Bokator. Over the last five
years, I have met, interviewed, photographed and trained with nearly
every
single Khmer Bokator master except for two or three who I plan to go see
when I return to Cambodia.
Grand Master San Kim Saen opened his school in Phnom Penh, which is the
largest Bokator club in Cambodia. He has had literally thousands of
students in the last few years alone. Most of the other masters I
visited
had at most twenty students, many of whom weren’t active. Grand Master
spent years codifying the system, writing it down, photographing it, and
collecting styles and movements from everywhere. The other masters all
had
their specialty, such as sword or stick or kick boxing, but San Kim Saen
was the only one with the complete style.
By traveling to various small Bokator clubs around the country you can
learn various techniques, but you can learn literally all of them at the
club in Phnom Penh.
No one knows the exact age of Bokator. The first known reference to
Bokator is in the carvings on the walls of Angkor Wat Temple, made
between
900 and 1,000 years ago. Anything else about the origin and history of
the
art is legend, theory and conjecture. The first articles written about
the
art are only a few years old.
Bradal Serey probably had very distinct styles at one time, but since
the
Khmer Rouge killed most of the masters and practitioners, the few who
survived have had to build up the art from nothing. As a result, Bradal
Serey is pretty much homogenous throughout the country. Also, as it is a
competitive, professional fighting sport, it is subjected to rules,
which
fairly standardize the art. There are differences from teacher to
teacher,
but these are more because of personalities, methods…not truly codified
style differences.
In Thailand there are two martial arts, Muay Thai and Krabi Krabong. If
you would consider Muay Thai Boran a separate art, then Thailand has
three
arts.
There are countless styles of Muay Thai depending on which part of the
country you come from and which master you follow, but it is all Muay
Thai. When they fight professionally the rules are the same.
Some styles, such as Muay Chaya are very old, and there are written
documents dating back several hundred years. Others, such as Muay Thai
Sangha, a religious form of Muay Thai, are fairly new, with the founder
still living.
Krabi Krabong is fighting with stick and sword. Krabi Krabong is often
incorporated into Muay Thai Boran to the point that it is almost never
taught separately.
Muay Thai Boran, Boran just means ancient, Muay Thai Boran has more
techniques than modern Muay Thai because it has many moves which would
be
illegal in professional fighting. Muay Thai Boran doesn’t use gloves, so
there is a bit more stand up grappling and throwing. Muay Thai Boran
also
doesn’t actually fight. So, there are more flying knees and flying
elbows
and techniques which are dramatic to watch. If you see a Tony Jaa film
you
will see Muay Thai Boran.
As a side note, there has been much debate as to whether Tony Jaa is
Khmer
or Thai and if his art is Bokator or Boran. There are even rumors he
trained in Cambodia. To find the answer, I traveled to Khmer Surin
province, Thailand, where I sought out and trained with Jaa’s first
teacher, Sok Chai. Accompanied by Khmer monk friends, I also visited his
house and interviewed his parents. We went to the elephant village where
Jaa was born and explored the temple where his father had been a monk.
The answer is, Jaa is from Khmer Surin, so he and his parents speak
Khmer
In fact, our interview was conducted in Khmer. His ethnicity however,
will
probably be a shock to all but die-hard fans. He is a member of the Kuytribe, who are the royal elephant keepers, who have served His Majesty,
the King of Thailand for generations. Jaa’s father confirmed that Jaa’s
first visit to Cambodia was tied to the release of the film “Ang Bak,”
So,
there is no way he could have studied Bokator in Cambodia before
becoming
fanmous. I also interviewed nearly every master in Cambodia, all of whom
confirmed that Jaa was never their student. Finally, his first teacher,
Ajan Sok Chai, who is also from Surin, is ethnic Thai, not Khmer. He
taught Tony Jaa Muay Thai Boran and movie fighting.
Saddly. it is nearly 100% certain that Jaa has never studied, and
possibly, never heard of Bokator.
Khmers believe that Muay Thai Boran was stolen from Bokator and this
would
explain similarities between the arts. No one knows for sure, but what
is
certain is that knowledge and borrowing of culture and martial arts
flowed
in both directions across the Thai-Cambodian border. It is unlikely that
there was ever a time that one or the other of these two countries
didn’t
have some type of fighting system.
With the possible exception of a very large sword academy outside of
Bangkok, Muay Thai Boran and Krabi Krabong are taught as extras at Muay.
Thai camps and schools. Because there are no professional fights in
these
two arts, fighters can’t afford to spend a lot of time learning them.
Most only pick up a few moves and spend their energy and time
concentrating on
the money art, Muay Thai.
Many traditionalist Muay Thai trainers teach their students legal Muay
Thai Boran moves because they believe that the old ways are the most
lethal in the ring. Famous people who fall into this category include
Prah
Khru Bah Neua Chai Kositto, Thailand’s last warrior monk, who I trained
with at Wat Acha Thong. The fighetrs learn the Boran style, but then get
in a real professional ring and fight for money. Another exception was
Kru
Pedro, who founded Muay Thai Sangha. He no longer allows his students to
fight for money, however. And, most famous of all was Nong Tum, the
“Beautiful Boxer.”
Whichever art came first, or who stole from whom, is a mute point.
Modern
Bokator is a codified martial art with a prescribed system of movements,
tests, and belts, taught in a systematic fashion, leading to Black Krama.
Muay Thai Boran/Krabi Krabong are generally taught sporadically, a few
moves here and there.
Bradal Serey, Muay Thai, Bokator, and Muay Thai Boran all include stand
up
grappling. In Thailand, the words “jap ko” are often used. This
literally
means, “grab the neck.” Only Bokator has ground fighting. Bokator
encompasses all of the movements of Bradal Serey plus all of the
movements of Khmer wrestling. In my Odyssey through southeast Asian martial arts,
Cambodia seemed to be the only country which still practices traditional
wrestling.
If Thailand ever had traditional wrestling, it has died out. I couldn’t
find traditional wrestling or martial art in Lao, although Muay Lao
(kickboxing) is still being trained and fought at the national stadium.
There is or was an ancient Lao form of martial art, called Ling Lam, but
I
was unable to find it while I was there. In Vietnam, the traditional
art,
Vo Vinam had some elements which were similar to Khmer arts, but seemed
more closely to resemble a mix of Chinese and North East Asian Arts.
There
were rumors that traditional wrestling still existed, but I was unable
to
find it. So, I will be returning to both Vietnam and Lao. Vietnam did
not
have a traditional kickboxing art of any kind. In fact there is no
professional fighting in Vietnam at all.
Antonio Graceffo is a martial arts and adventure author living in Asia. He is the host “Martial Arts Odyssey,” a web TV show which traces his ongoing journey through Asia, learning martial arts in various countries. See it on YoutTube.com.
Disclaimer:
The opinions, sentiments and views expressed in Opinion Sections of the
Ambassadors
Magazine are not necessarily shared by the magazine's staff, management or editorial board.
